One hour and thirty minutes of New York noise—then laughs. At Broadway Comedy Club, you get a headline-style stand-up lineup in a super convenient Times Square area setting, often with a bunch of comics packed into one show. From what I can piece together from real-world feedback, two things I really like are the sheer number of acts in a short slot and how the staff can be flexible about where you sit (one person even mentioned getting moved to a table in back when it helped their needs). The main thing to consider is that the two-drink minimum and the small, sometimes messy-feeling room aren’t for everyone.

You’ll also appreciate that there’s a choice of show times, so you can fit comedy around dinner instead of building your whole night backward. The drawback is that the humor level can swing: some shows feel killer, while others land flat for part of the lineup, so if you’re very picky about comedy, you might want to treat this as a fun gamble rather than a guarantee.

Key things to know before you go

• 90 minutes, multiple comics: Expect a lineup that can run long on stage time even within an hour and a half.
• Two drink minimum: Alcohol is available, but it’s not required—still, you must order two drinks per person.
• No late seating: Plan to arrive about 30 minutes early and check in before the seating line forms.
• Mobile ticket: You’ll receive an email ticket you can show on your phone (print is optional).
• Small venue reality: Seating can feel tight, and cleanliness is mixed depending on the night.
• Comedy varies: Individual acts can change without notice, so every show won’t feel identical.

Times Square Comedy Club logistics: how to get there and get seated

Broadway Comedy Club is built for easy foot traffic. You’re in the Times Square orbit, with near public transportation, so you can usually plan around subway and short walks instead of long travel time. The big practical tip is timing: there’s no late seating, so don’t drift in right when the show starts.

Your best move is to arrive about 30 minutes early and check in with the door before you queue up for seating. That keeps you from losing your place or missing the moment when staff start directing people into the room.

Inside, it’s a compact comedy setup. Some people describe it as crowded or basement-like in feel, which matches the reality of a lot of Manhattan entertainment spaces. If you’re sensitive to tight rooms, this is where your expectations need to be realistic: you’re going for stand-up, not spacious comfort.

Price and value: the real cost behind the $25 ticket

The ticket price is $25 per person, and admission is included. But the true cost comes from the two drink minimum. Drinks are not included, and the club requires two beverages per person, whether you drink alcohol or not.

Here’s how to think about the value:

• If you’re the type who enjoys staying put and letting the show run, the drink minimum actually works in your favor. It discourages constant bathroom runs and keeps the room from breaking rhythm.
• If you don’t drink, you’re still paying for two sodas, water, or other non-alcohol options. One person said they paid for four cokes in total and felt the minimum was too much for what they wanted.
• Drink prices can be a shock. Some feedback puts soda around the $6 range, while water was reported as higher in at least one case (around $7.28). Another review called out an added service charge/gratuity surprise.

So I’d budget beyond $25. Even if you choose inexpensive non-alcohol drinks, your final bill will usually feel like part of the ticket experience. The good news: alcohol is not required, so you can keep it simple if you prefer.

The show format in 90 minutes: what the lineup feels like

This isn’t a single-comedian night where you wait for the headliner and then leave. The show is built around multiple acts. Based on what people report, you may see six to ten comedians in roughly 90 minutes, with different styles and different energy levels across the lineup.

Broadway Comedy Club markets the night as headliner-focused, featuring comedians from New York City with special guests from across the country. You’ll also see names and credits referenced in their pitch—comics who have appeared on MTV, HBO, The Tonight Show, Comedy Central, The Daily Show, and more. The important part for you isn’t the branding; it’s the variety.

Two realities to plan for:

• You might love most of the set list: Several people said they laughed hard all the way through and praised the MC and the overall energy.
• You might get a mixed bag: Other reviews mention that a few comedians were weak or not landing with the crowd, and one reviewer said humor can get raunchy at times.

And yes, comedian appearances can change without notice. So the show you get is the one in the room that night—not the one you imagine reading about it online.

Seating, sightlines, and that tight-comedy-room feeling

Seating is where the experience splits. Some people report getting great seats, including front-row setups. Others say the seats were cramped or not comfortable, and a few mentioned the room felt small or crowded.

If you need a practical approach, do this:

• Pick a show time that matches your tolerance for crowds. Prime evening slots can feel more packed than earlier ones.
• If your seating matters for sound or access, arrive early. With no late seating, you can’t depend on last-minute fixes after you walk in.
• If there’s a seating adjustment available, staff can sometimes help. One person specifically mentioned staff accommodating a request to move to a table in the back.

Keep in mind: it’s still a comedy club room, so even with decent seating, you’re close to strangers and the vibe can get loud. If you want a quiet, private night out, this isn’t the format.

Drinks, service, and the pacing between sets

You’ll experience table service and drink ordering during the show. Reviews include two very different takes on this:

• Some people described service as fine, even friendly, with staff helpful about seating and drink delivery.
• Others complained that staff or the bar person kept walking around ordering drinks while comics were performing, which can feel distracting.

Drink minimums also change how the show feels. If everyone has already ordered their two drinks, the rhythm can stay smoother. If not, you may notice more commotion around check-ins, payments, and refills.

One review praised a waiter named Giota (spelling as reported) and mentioned the drinks like an amaretto sour being excellent. Another mentioned Dina as getting them great seats. Those details matter because they point to a real possibility: when the staff is on it, the night feels effortless.

The flip side is cleanliness. A few people reported bad odors right when they walked in and dirty bathrooms. Others said toilets were less than perfect but still manageable. So I’d treat venue cleanliness as variable, not guaranteed.

Who this comedy night is best for (and who should skip it)

This show fits best if you:

• Want an easy Times Square night plan with a low-friction start.
• Like stand-up where you don’t need to see one specific comic. The lineup is a mix, and the room energy matters.
• Are with a partner or even teenage kids. One family said it worked well for teens who were curious and ended up laughing a lot.

It’s less ideal if you:

• Hate the idea of a two-drink minimum and want to pay only for what you consume. Even with non-alcoholic options, you’re still paying for two drinks per person.
• Are sensitive to raunchy humor. Some reviews noted sexual, identity, and race-related jokes.
• Have strong cleanliness standards. If bathrooms and odors are a deal-breaker, you may want to choose a different venue.

Also, if you’re going to treat comedy like a sure thing, temper that. Even at the same club, different lineups and crowd reactions can change how funny it feels.

Booking smart: show times, mobile ticket, and what not to forget

You can choose show times, which makes it easier to build a full evening in NYC. I like that approach because you’re not stuck with one rigid schedule. Want dinner first? Pick a later show. Want to do a quick Times Square loop and then retreat indoors? Pick an earlier slot.

Booking is also common in advance. On average, this experience gets booked about 17 days ahead, so it’s smart to grab your date early if you’re traveling in a busy window.

For entry, it’s simple:

• You get an email ticket after you book.
• You can show the mobile ticket on your phone at the door. Printing is optional.
• You should bring some form of ID if staff ask, especially because age rules are strict.

Age rules are clear: you must be 16+, or 13+ with parents. That matters if you’re traveling with teens.

Finally, know that seating isn’t forgiving. With no late seating, your plan needs buffer time. Comedy clubs aren’t like museums—show start is show start.

Should you book Broadway Comedy Club in Times Square?

If you’re okay with paying for the two-drink minimum and you want a fast, action-packed stand-up night close to Times Square, I’d say it’s worth booking. The upside is real: multiple comics in a short window, frequent laughs, and an easy schedule that can fit dinner plans.

But if you’re going in expecting polished comfort, guaranteed top-tier comedy every act, and spotless facilities, treat this as a gamble. The room can feel cramped, drink costs can add up quickly, and humor can range from hit to miss.

My practical recommendation: book it if stand-up is your thing and you’re ready to order two drinks. Skip it if cleanliness, quiet, and strict budgets matter more than laughs.